Find Creative Treats for Trick-or-Treaters in New Mexico

There are lots of things to do in October in New Mexico, but we haven’t forgotten about Halloween. Everyone’s getting ready! If you’re planning to be home and handing out treats, this year, and if you want your house to stand out, then you need some creative trick-or-treat ideas. With these unique and eye-catching treats for trick-or-treaters in New Mexico, you won’t be just another house on the block. Whether you plan to decorate, or simply turn on the porch light, the kids in your neighborhood are going to love these funny, freaky, and festive treats.

Find Funny Treats for Trick-or-Treaters in New Mexico

If you’re looking for something sweet that will get a laugh from the trick-or-treaters at your door, you can’t go wrong with Candy Gag Gifts from the Candy Warehouse. They have Goofy Monster Lollipops, Twisted Lip Pops, Gummy Mustaches and Blob Monsters, and even Shakespearean Insult Gum.

For those who can’t help but giggle at toilet humor (and what kid doesn’t?), they’ve got Potty Mouth Toilet Pops, colorful Sour Flush Candy Toilets, Rainbow Poop Swirl Pops, and Dinosaur Roaring Candy Poopers.

If you want to make the kids laugh with a non-candy treat or provide options for kids with food sensitivities, there are plenty of affordable Halloween novelty toys at the Oriental Trading Company. The Oriental Trading Company is the oldest wholesale company in the US with value-priced novelty items and party supplies. You can find Wacky Monster Bendables, Monster Pop Up toys, Jack-O’-Lantern Whoopie Cushions, and colorful Mini Noise Putties. They also have Monster Wind Up Chomping Teeth and the funny Nose, Eyebrows, and Mustache Glasses.

Find Freaky Treats for Trick-or-Treaters in New Mexico

To hand out treats that are a little more spooky, creepy, or weird will find plenty of material to work with. For a very simple DIY treat, make some creepy severed hand goodie bags with rubber gloves and candy.

If you’re not looking for a DIY project, then head on over to the Candy Warehouse and grab these spooky Creature Eyes Lollipops and the Zombie Hand Lollipops, which are certain to make a lasting impression. You can also find Sour Candy Blood Vials, Crime Scene Candy Tubes, and Gummy Internal Organs. If you didn’t plan to get quite so gruesome, Scary Shapes Gummies might be the better choice.

To spook trick-or-treaters with something less sugary, the Oriental Trading Company has great deals on Jumping Spiders, Stretchable Flying Bats, and Glow in the Dark Spiders. They also sell Brain-Shaped Splat Balls, Zombie Finger Bubble Bottles, Glow in the Dark Eyeball Slime, and Sticky Slugs.

Find Festive Treats for Trick-or-Treaters in New Mexico

Maybe you aren’t trying to make an impression as the funny guy or gal on the block, and you don’t really want to freak anyone out, either. You might just want to hand out some exceptionally creative, unique, and festive treats. If you’re trying to be more festive for Halloween, rather than funny or freaky, then these awesome Wax Lips Halloween Candies from the Candy Warehouse are a great choice. They’ve also got expertly decorated Large Pumpkin Pops, Mini Halloween Unicorn Pops, and amazing Candy Corn Ring Suckers.

Many prefer to give trick-or-treaters in New Mexico a range of candies and toys that represent Dia de los Muertos, the Day of the Dead. While some keep this holiday quite separate from Halloween, others like to blend the two together. If you prefer Dia de los Muertos, you’ll want the Cookies n Cream Candy Skulls and Day of the Dead Skull Hard Candy Lollipops. Get an even better deal with the delicious Day of the Dead Buttermint Creams. The Day of the Dead Sweet Skull Lip Pops are another unique and creative option.

There are also plenty of festive candy alternatives for your trick-or-treaters in New Mexico. The Oriental Trading Company has Watch it Grow Pumpkins, Neon Skeleton Bendables, and Day of the Dead Maracas. They also have adorable Monster Character Bubbles, bright Skull Plush toys, Spider Pinwheels, and plush Halloween Cats. 

Shop Local for Trick-or-Treaters in New Mexico

You may have noticed by now that the best places to find hilarious, creepy, and celebratory treats for trick-or-treaters in New Mexico include the Candy Warehouse for sweets and the Oriental Trading Company for non-sweet treats. These are the two best sources for those who want to deliver the very best this Halloween, and their products are easily accessible and affordable online. Of course, many prefer to buy local and in person.

Check Out Halloween and Party Stores

If you want to get your Halloween treats from a local shop, there are many places to look. There’s a Spirit Halloween store near you if you live around Albuquerque, Farmington, or Las Cruces. If you’re close to El Paso, Texas, you could head over there to check out the larger Spirit Halloween Superstore.

Spirit Halloween has an amazing selection of party favors and supplies. You can find Black Spider, Colorful Spider, and Glow in the Dark Spider toys. They have Vampire Teeth, creepy Cut Off Fingers, and fashionable Skull Bracelets.  If you need other supplies, decorations, or costumes, you’ll find everything at the same place.

Another good store for those who wish to shop locally near Albuquerque or Santa Fe is Party City. You’ll discover a nice variety of Halloween candy and a diverse selection of non-candy Halloween treats. They have everything from Halloween Eyeball Glasses to money-saving 100-pack units of assorted Halloween favors.  They even have 120-count packs of temporary Halloween tattoos that all kids love.

Those who live near Farmington should take a peek at the local Celebrations Party Store and More. They are stocked up with Halloween supplies.

Save Money at a Dollar Tree Near You

One of the most affordable options that virtually everyone in New Mexico and around the US can turn to is your local Dollar Tree. Everything $1, and there are dozens of locations throughout the state.

At your local Dollar Tree, you’re going to find inexpensive Halloween candy, treats, and party favors. View the Dollar Tree Halloween Catalog to see what they’re selling this year. You should also take a look at their DIY Halloween page. They share simple and cost effective instructions for creating clever and customizable treats for trick-or-treaters in New Mexico. Make Witch’s Broom Treat Bags, with candy or toys of your choosing, and Glittery Bat Ornaments, for a sparkly, non-candy Halloween decoration the kids can keep.

Let us know what you’re planning to hand out to your trick-or-treaters in New Mexico this Halloween. And if you know of any local New Mexican shops that stock treats for Halloween, please share in the comments!